Score: 1

"punk yeh?"

submission: Aratic-Contempt of Courtship

date: December 15, 2009

sounds like MCR. to me that's not punk at all. this is emo/rock. and no, i'm not stereotyping, it sounds like a MCr B-side and the lyrics whine about love and relationships... its emo. say whatever you want in response, i don't care, it's my opinion and i'm allowed to have it. not everyone is going to tell you it's amazing...

anyway, it's good for what it is. nice production and stuff. and you can sing. it's just NOT PUNK and it pisses me off when people call it punk because then leigons of impressionable teenagers think punk is about this bullshit. when it's not. anyway, whatever.

Score: 8

"sweet dude"

submission: Sly Wayz

date: June 14, 2008

best yet man SERIOUS. the bass is nice and round, a little clean for my tastes but still good. the effects are minimal but that works cos it puts emphasis on the bass. the beat is nice and crisp and simple. keep at it man, this is your best yet by far!

pyromantis x)

Score: 2

"bloody crap"

submission: NEW - Smiles and Glances

date: March 24, 2008

good until the vocals came in. how many times does someone have to say THIS IS NOT PUNK before people take notice. punk is about not giving a fuck, and all this music whining about girls and romance and all that shit is the OPPOSITE OF THAT. i mean, this sounds like Busted. think up some new chord progressions and lyrics that don't involve girls, breakups, romance, crying, high school and being a dork and maybe people who like punk will like this.

Score: 8

"nice job so far"

submission: Distant Lust prev. [DUBSTEP]

date: March 11, 2008

in my opinion the bass is a little hollow and there's not quite enough of it. and i agree with nxt man, the gritty synth is great, but atm it kind of overshadows the bass. keep working on it, you'll get it perfect soon i'm sure. check out my new dub tune btw, Green Goblin, see what ya think. safe.

pyro x)

Score: 9

"fantastic"

submission: Dj Otherworld - Dreamride

date: February 21, 2008

i prefer a harder edge to my beats, but still, fantabulous mate! i try to make stuff with the depth and scope of this, but it's so hard when all i've got is Garageband at college. I gave it a go and made a few dubstep tunes too, so give em a listen and give yer pro opinion if you get time. cheers!

Pyromantis x)

Score: 6

"good effort"

submission: BodyBreak [DubStep]

date: February 21, 2008

The bass was perfect, but there wasn't enough of it. It was just kind of a bit heree and there and the same thing all the way thru. Nice intro tho.

Pyro x)

Score: 8

"nice job"

submission: Vindict [DUBSTEP]

date: February 21, 2008

it's a solid dubstep tune. the bass is a little hollow but i have trouble getting a juicy, fat bass wobble. maybe add some melodies over the top nxt time; 2 mins of bass gets a little old. nice job tho, what program do u use?

Score: 9

"Dodgy title but..."

submission: {stales} Small Infant On The..

date: February 21, 2008

...good song. Lots of piano layers and it gets better as it goes on. keep it up man.

Pyro x)

Score: 10

"amazing!"

submission: Battle of Marx

date: February 5, 2008

i hope you didn't just lift this off the SNES. it sounds very very much like the original. and unless you unlock the little music player, you can only listen to it while actually fighting MARX. nice job.

Score: 8

"faithful"

submission: Kirby's Dream Land - Credits

date: February 5, 2008

i suppose you synth'd this yerself and didn't just rip it off the GB. nice, faithful recreation. now do the one for the end credits of Kirby's Fun Pak on the SNES, and i'll be overjoyed.